
Nostalgia 2.0: Swiss primal feeling becomes a consumer product
Nostalgia was invented at the University of Basel in 1688 as a diagnosis for homesick mercenaries. Today, it is used to sell us remakes, Lego sets, and TV series. A search for traces from the disease to the consumer product.
For millennials, aka anyone whose body has recently started making noises when getting up, Christmas falls on November 5th this year. That is when the remake of «The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time» is released. According to Metacritic, it is the best game of all time; according to our ranking, it is at least the second best, right behind «D̶e̶a̶d̶ ̶o̶r̶ ̶A̶l̶i̶v̶e̶:̶ ̶X̶T̶r̶e̶m̶e̶ ̶B̶e̶a̶c̶h̶ ̶V̶o̶l̶l̶e̶y̶b̶a̶l̶l̶»̶ «World of Warcraft».
«Ocarina of Time» is inextricably linked to my childhood. Along with «Final Fantasy VII», Link's adventure was one of the first video games to show me how limitless this medium can feel. Cynics like to claim that most «Zelda» stories could fit on a beer mat. They aren't entirely wrong. Nevertheless, when I first stepped out of Kokiri Forest and the vast fields of Hyrule lay before me, I felt as though I were in an epic of Tolkien-esque proportions.

Source: Nintendo
Such experiences burn themselves into your memory. They are highly emotional moments of happiness that many of us try to reproduce years later. Sometimes consciously, sometimes unconsciously, we drift into nostalgia.
But what is actually behind this feeling? The answer is more complex and (hopefully) more exciting than you think.
What is nostalgia?
There is hardly a lazier journalistic stylistic device than quoting the dictionary. But here, it makes sense. The dictionary describes nostalgia as follows:
a mood triggered by discomfort with the present, filled with an indefinite longing, which manifests itself in a turning back to a past time, transfigured in the imagination, whose fashion, art, music, etc., one revives
Wait, that's a contradiction. Actually, we associate nostalgia with something positive. Why should the warm, fuzzy feeling that comes over me during the «Duck Tales» intro arise from discomfort?
The answer lies in the original meaning of the word. Until the 19th century, nostalgia was a medical diagnosis. It was coined by medical student Johannes Hofer in 1688 in his dissertation at the University of Basel.
For the term, he combined two Greek words: «nóstos» (homecoming) and «álgos» (pain). It simply meant homesickness, albeit a pathological one that could, in the worst case, end in death. Hofer observed it primarily in Swiss mercenaries, then one of our country's most important exports. Tens of thousands of young men from villages and hamlets served in foreign armies. They were far from home, and news from back home only arrived if one of their 14 siblings had died from a pig bite or the local bailiff had set fire to the family farm.

Source: Wikipedia
Unsurprisingly, many of them sank into melancholy. The phenomenon was so closely linked to the Swiss that people abroad spoke of the «Mal du Suisse», the Swiss disease. And it even had its own soundtrack: the Kuhreihen.
The alpine herdsmen used these traditional melodies to call their cattle together. However, the «Lo-Fi Beats to Herd Cows To» had a side effect when abroad. They intensified the homesickness. Swiss mercenaries were therefore forbidden from singing or whistling them, allegedly under threat of the death penalty. Fortunately, such draconian punishments today only exist if someone plays a Yoko Ono song.
Hofer's diagnosis was later further developed by various scholars, but it increasingly lost its significance over the course of the 19th century because it lacked a scientific foundation. Nostalgia then migrated into psychiatry, where it was treated as a form of melancholy. There, the clinical picture was increasingly softened until the view finally prevailed that nostalgia is nothing more than a longing for a past time.
A bit sad perhaps, but by no means fatal.
Nostalgia 2.0
From a disease to a consumer product, it wasn't a long way. Nostalgia became a business model in 1970s America, a decade that had plenty of discomfort with the present to offer, with Vietnam, Watergate, and the oil crisis. Exactly the breeding ground that the dictionary definition suggests. Films like George Lucas' «American Graffiti» (1973) painted an idealized picture of the past that confirmed the audience's «everything was better back then» attitude.
What was shown often had little to do with reality, but our memory is notoriously a lousy archivist. Who wants facts when you can have a time instead where kids still sat nicely in the milk bar instead of smoking weed behind the gym?
In the 80s, «Back to the Future» and «The Wonder Years» picked up on the success formula. When «That '70s Show» started ten years later, the concept was long established. It was finally perfected by Netflix, with «Stranger Things» and the associated marketing machinery.

Source: Netflix
The gaming industry followed suit. Thanks to the retro market, nostalgia had long been a topic here, but the big publishers served it rather cautiously. That changed with the HD generation and its wave of remasters and remakes, which still feels like it fills half the release calendar today. For the corporations, this is a grateful business: re-releasing well-known brands is far less risky than inventing new ones. And for a guaranteed profit, most CEOs would even give up their favorite hobby: firing 1,500 people via Teams call and then letting themselves be celebrated on LinkedIn for the «difficult decision».
It's no different off-screen. Whether Lego sets, «Magic» cards, or Funko Pops: the entire pop culture has committed itself to nostalgia. The market delivers because we buy. However, there is a reason why we are currently doing so diligently.
Why does nostalgia feel so good?
Sociologist Fred Davis already examined the nostalgia wave in 1979 in his book «Yearning for Yesterday». It contains a lot of clever things, including arguably the most important psychological reason why Lego can sell a «Star Wars» Death Star for the price of an overseas flight.

Source: Lego
According to Davis, nostalgia gives us stability. Especially when society or one's own life falls apart. And oh boy, both have been shaky lately. There is war in Europe, democracy is wavering, the cost of living is rising, and this morning I got the top score in the «How quickly will AI replace your job?» quiz. Good job, everybody.
The uncertainty gnaws at us, and we feel powerless. What could be more natural than returning to Hyrule, to a simpler, better time? Whether it was really better doesn't matter to me. I can blast a Deku nut into the eye of the spider queen Gohma with my fairy slingshot and for a moment forget that health insurance premiums have risen again.
For the same reason, I prefer to watch seasons 1 to 8 of «The Simpsons» for the 18th time instead of starting a new series. I know what to expect. Homer's simple-mindedness is my emotional anchor in the past.
The memory bump
The fact that we look for this stability so often in our youth has two main reasons. The first is simple: for many of us, it was actually carefree. You came home from school and knew: now four hours of «GTA: Vice City» and no one wants anything from you afterwards. Today, you drag yourself onto the sofa after your terrible workday at the Terrible Workday Factory and are too exhausted to do anything active.

Source: Rockstar Games
The second is called «Reminiscence Bump». It describes a phenomenon that occurs in adults from about 30 onwards: they remember experiences from their youth and early adult years disproportionately strongly. Roughly between 10 and 30, we go through the most formative phase of our identity formation. Films, music, and games that we consume during this time therefore often accompany us into old age and act as a kind of glue that holds our personality together.
The facts on this are thin, but I believe that no other medium triggers nostalgia as reliably as video games. Gaming is immersive. I don't just see the moments again, I experience them. I walk the same paths, defeat the same enemies, hear the same melodies, and – with a bit of luck – feel the same euphoria as in 1998.
Video games are a time machine. And it is available to me at any time.
Is nostalgia good for us?
Many find nostalgia bittersweet, with the sweet usually outweighing the bitter. And for once, we don't have to fear the dentist or diabetes. This is confirmed by several studies by social psychologist Constantine Sedikides. Together with his team at the University of Southampton, he has effectively issued a rehabilitation report for nostalgia.
Nostalgia lifts the mood, strengthens self-esteem, and can help against loneliness. Moreover: «Nostalgia makes us a bit more human», says Sedikides in the «New York Times».

Source: Rainer Etzweiler
So, the mental time travel is not quite as dangerous as Hofer wanted us to believe over 300 years ago. A residual risk remains, however. There are indications that a pronounced tendency towards nostalgia can tip into rumination: thought loops that revolve around missed opportunities or wrong decisions, for example.
Psychologist Bas Verplanken showed in 2012 that nostalgia actually increases anxiety and depression in notorious ruminators instead of alleviating them. And a team from the University of Southern California found in 2020 that nostalgia in everyday life, i.e., when it overcomes us unasked, has a significantly worse effect on mood.
It may be a worn-out phrase, but those who spend too much time in the past miss the present. And only in the present can we create new beautiful moments. Moments that trigger the same warm, fuzzy feeling years later as our first excursion into the vast fields of Hyrule.
So: enjoy your return to Hyrule, but don't get lost in it. Except in the Water Temple. That's part of the experience.
In the early 90s, my older brother gave me his NES with The Legend of Zelda on it. It was the start of an obsession that continues to this day.
Interesting facts about products, behind-the-scenes looks at manufacturers and deep-dives on interesting people.
Show all













