Opinion

Charging money for advance access to games should be banned

16/10/2024

Translation: Patrik Stainbrook

Paying 30 francs/euros extra to play a game two weeks before release is a sad reality. This has to stop.

EA was one of the first publishers to sell deluxe editions of its games before their official release. For a developer that’s been voted worst company in the USA several times, this strategy wasn’t surprising. As a result, most gamers paid little attention to the whole thing. Turns out EA was only the first assault.

Playing a game earlier for an extra charge has long been normalised, and offers are becoming increasingly brazen. The most recent example is Life is Strange: Double Exposure from publisher Square Enix. Their adventure game will be officially released on 29 October for 49.90 francs/euros. If you fork out an extra 30, you can play the game a whole two weeks earlier. Well, nobody's forcing you to, you may be thinking. True, but with a story-focused game like Life is Strange: Double Exposure, you run the risk of being spoiled if you wait until the official release.

This is probably how most people will look when they realise they have to pay 60 per cent more to play Life is Strange: Double Exposure right away.
Source: Square Enix

Even in games such as Test Drive Unlimited: Solar Crown, where the only spoilers are at the rear of racing cars, more easily tempted gamers are shamelessly exploited. Manufacturers ask you to pay through the nose for your FOMO. With Solar Crown, publisher Nacon even created different levels. The Silver Edition let you play two days earlier, the Gold Edition a whole week. The Steam reviews are correspondingly scathing.

Here are some examples of games with premium advance access from this year and last year, compiled by game blog Kotaku.

Assassin’s Creed Shadows – 3 days (now withdrawn)
Age of Mythology Retold – 7 days
Baldur’s Gate 3 (PS5) – 4 days
College Football 25 – 3 days
Concord – 3 days
Diablo 4 – 5 days
Dragon Ball: Sparking! ZERO – 3 days
EA Sports FC 25 – 7 days
Forza Motorsport – 5 days
Earth Defense Force 6 – 1 day
Enotria: The Last Song – 3 days
Lies of P – 3 days
Life Is Strange: Double Exposure – 14 days
Madden NFL 25 – 3 days
Monster Jam Showdown – 3 days
Mortal Kombat 1 – 5 days
Silent Hill 2 – 2 days
Sonic X Shadow Generations – 3 days
Starfield – 5 days
Star Wars Outlaws – 3 days
Space Marine II – 4 days
Sword Art Online Fractured Daydream – 3 days
Test Drive Unlimited Solar Crown – 2 to 7 days
The Crew Motorfest – 3 days
Undisputed – 3 days
Visions of Mana – 1 day

Pay to be a beta tester

As if all this wasn’t bad enough, you’re often faced with a double whammy here. With many games, you don’t so much buy yourself advance access, but rather the right to be a beta tester. It’s not uncommon for a huge update to drop at the actual launch. Before that, you always have to deal with annoying bugs. This is particularly frustrating if you have to delete your save and start all over again – as happens in the obviously unfinished Star Wars Outlaws. To me, Deluxe, Gold and Premium mean something different.

Paying more and dealing with save game bugs is part and parcel in the deluxe version of Star Wars Outlaws.
Source: Ubisoft

At least Ubisoft rolled back its plans for Assassin’s Creed Shadows, foregoing a more expensive pre-release version. However, the phenomenon won’t disappear. Sure, we could do without all this. But when a new, eagerly awaited game’s available a few days earlier and it feels like everyone’s talking about it, many players give in.

So, in my opinion, this nasty scheming should be banned. Publishers and manufacturers should earn money with real content, not by exploiting well-off and weaker-willed gamers. I’m one of the latter by the way and off to play Life is Strange: Double Exposure. In protest, mind you.

81 people like this article

Philipp Rüegg

Senior Editor

Philipp.Rueegg@digitecgalaxus.ch

As a child, I wasn't allowed to have any consoles. It was only with the arrival of the family's 486 PC that the magical world of gaming opened up to me. Today, I'm overcompensating accordingly. Only a lack of time and money prevents me from trying out every game there is and decorating my shelf with rare retro consoles.

Opinion

This is a subjective opinion of the editorial team. It doesn't necessarily reflect the position of the company.

Show all

These articles might also interest you

Opinion
Deluxe editions are one of the most annoying things in the gaming world
by Domagoj Belancic
Opinion
Why I’m unimpressed by the trailer for The Mandalorian and Grogu
by Luca Fontana
Opinion
Everything was better in the old days – why kart racers urgently need to bring back story mode
by Cassie Mammone