Background information

Is Nintendo making the same mistake with the Switch 2 as Sony did with the PS3?

10/4/2025

Translation: Patrik Stainbrook

Is Nintendo putting an end to low-cost consoles? At launch, the Switch 2 will cost almost as much as the PS5. However, the console has more parallels to the PS3. Still, Nintendo’s unlikely to suffer the same fate as Sony.

The price of the Switch 2 and especially its games are causing red heads. While Nintendo consoles were previously seen as affordable family devices, you’ll have to dig deeper into your pockets for the Switch 2. Something that brings back unpleasant memories from Sony in 2006.

In contrast to the mic-drop moment at the price announcement for the affordable PS1, the audience gulped blankly when the PS3 was shown off.
Source: YouTube/Noclip

Sony judged poorly

20 years ago, the company behind PlayStation was surfing a huge wave of success thanks to the PS2. With over 160 million units purchased, it’s still the best-selling console of all time. This high tempted Sony to charge a higher fee for the PS3. Players had to fork out 499.99 dollars for the 20 GB version, and 599.99 dollars for the 60 GB model. Today, that’d be 790 and 950 dollars respectively. However, Sony overestimated its own popularity. Just one year later, the company cut prices by 100 dollars to keep pace with the cheaper Xbox 360 and Wii.

With the Switch 2, Nintendo is finding itself in a similar situation. The original Switch is currently the third-best selling console ever with over 150 million units sold, just behind the Nintendo DS. Launched in 2007, that hybrid console was a huge success for the Japanese company. However, while the first Switch hit shelves for 299.99 dollars, the successor will cost 449 dollars. Adjusted for inflation, that’s a premium of 80 dollars.

Switzerland isn’t the same as the USA

Nevertheless, the Switch 2 will «only» be the third most expensive Nintendo console of all time – based on US prices. Mind you, price markups used to be rare. In the 80s and 90s, the Japanese game developer stuck to the same price of 199 dollars for quite some time. It wasn’t until 2006 that the company dared to charge 50 dollars more for the Wii.

So, the Switch 2 isn’t cheap. You can get a PS5 from 400 francs/euros, a significantly stronger console. It isn’t portable, though. In turn, Nintendo is also saving on accessories. The supplied Joy-Con grip, which turns two Joy-Cons into one controller, again has no charging function. That model costs extra. Just like the integrated chat function, which is launched using the new C button. It’ll only work with the paid Nintendo Online subscription. Without that, the button is useless.

For a long time, Nintendo’s consoles were released much later in Switzerland than in the USA and other European countries. By the time we were able to buy the NES in Migros, the Super Nintendo was already in American stores. It isn’t surprising then that the first Nintendo console to hit Switzerland is the cheapest of all. The most expensive is the Switch 2, closely followed by the Nintendo 64.

To better compare with the USA, I’ve also converted the Swiss prices to the dollar exchange rates at the time and then raised them to 2025 using a US inflation calculator. I haven’t taken VAT into account.

Price trends in Switzerland can’t be compared 1:1 with the USA. Firstly, purchasing power and inflation will be different. Secondly, I took the prices for the NES, SNES, Nintendo 64 and Gamecube from old Migros ads. It’s possible that other places had different prices. Official Swiss prices only followed much later. And only since the Wii have the consoles been released more or less at the same time worldwide.

Ad in Brückenbauer, the predecessor to the Migros newspaper: here, the NES is advertised with Super Mario Bros. for 210 francs. The ad dates back to October 1991.
Source: Migros

How much is Mario Kart worth?

US Nintendo boss Doug Bowser justifies the high price with improved hardware and an overall improved gaming experience compared to its predecessor. However, the price should have nothing to do with new US tariffs.

The main difference to Sony, who miscalculated for the PlayStation 3, is in games. No one else offers as many exclusive blockbusters – Super Mario, The Legend of Zelda and Pokémon, to name a few. Mario Kart 8 alone sold over 67.35 million copies. This makes it not only the best-selling Switch game by far, but also the fifth best-selling game ever – including Wii U sales. Nintendo now wants to take advantage of this.

You’ll have to dig deep into your pockets for Mario Kart World, unless you buy it in a bundle with the console.
Source: Nintendo

After all, the company’s own games are also becoming drastically more expensive. Probably the most popular of them all, Mario Kart World, will run you a whopping 70 dollars – for the digital version. For the physical version, Nintendo’s even demanding 80 dollars. The improved Switch 2 version of The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild will cost 80 US dollars. Reminder, that game was originally released for the Wii U. And the expansion isn’t included either. The standard price for AAA games is generally around 60 US dollars. However, Sony and Microsoft have already raised this to 70 US dollars for some titles with the launch of the PS5 and Xbox Series respectively. Nintendo also charged ten dollars more for The Legend of Zelda Tears of the Kingdom.

Nintendo’s also charging more for the new Donkey Kong Bananza, but ten dollars less than for Mario Kart World. Bowser calls this a flexible pricing policy, and the company obviously intends to stick to it. According to him, each game is a unique experience, so they have to vary prices accordingly. At least, that’s what the Head of Nintendo of America told The Verge.

Falling game prices

Historically, however, the new game prices aren’t as steep as they appear. This was revealed in an evaluation by tech blog Arstechnica. In the 1990s, absolute game prices rose sharply. Only the advent of CD-ROMs and digital games led to a reduction in prices. Adjusted for inflation, things look different again. Centipede for the Atari 2600 cost 34.99 US dollars in 1983. That’s almost 90 US dollars today. The Migros ad from 1991 shown above advertises NES games that cost between 65 and 115 francs. Today, this would be up to 149 francs. The chart also shows that actual game prices have fallen steadily since the end of the 1990s.

Over the past 30 years, game prices have fallen consistently when inflation is factored in.
Source: Kyle Orland/Ars Technica

So, 80 dollars for Mario Kart World isn’t exceptionally expensive in a historical context. And when you consider the prices being bandied about for GTA 6, it’s almost bearable. Apparently, Rockstar could charge up to 100 US dollars for its next hit, analysts predict. But while the open-world gangster adventure could cost a billion dollars to make including marketing, Nintendo is likely to have invested a fraction of that in Mario Kart World.

The slightly improved version of The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, originally developed for the Wii U, will be released at a premium price on the Switch 2.
Source: Nintendo

It’s true, Nintendo could get away with higher prices thanks to its unique portfolio. However, their fans have also shown that they won’t put up with everything. Nintendo pulled the handbrake on the 3DS after less than four months, lowering the retail price from 250 to 170 US dollars. Whether this’ll happen again with the Switch 2, however, is questionable.

The Switch 2 will be released on 5 June. Then, or rather in the weeks and months following that, we’ll see whether Nintendo miscalculated or whether Mario and co. are strong enough draws.

We talked more about this topic in the newest episode of our German-language Tech-telmechtel podcast

131 people like this article

Philipp Rüegg

Senior Editor

Philipp.Rueegg@digitecgalaxus.ch

As a child, I wasn't allowed to have any consoles. It was only with the arrival of the family's 486 PC that the magical world of gaming opened up to me. Today, I'm overcompensating accordingly. Only a lack of time and money prevents me from trying out every game there is and decorating my shelf with rare retro consoles.

Background information

Interesting facts about products, behind-the-scenes looks at manufacturers and deep-dives on interesting people.

Show all

These articles might also interest you

Background information
Why the DS is the most successful handheld of all time
by Cassie Mammone
Background information
Nintendo absolutely nailed the Switch
by Domagoj Belancic
Background information
Robots, 3D cameras and infrared sensors: Nintendo gimmicks nobody needed
by Cassie Mammone